Seattle
  • Current Conditions
    50°
    Drizzle
  • 1:00pm
    51°
  • 4:00pm
    50°
Full Forecast »
Severe Weather Alert
Affected Counties
Related To Story
Biting an apple

Do Some Foods Take More Than They Give?

Negative-Calorie Foods May Be Just A Myth

POSTED: 12:09 pm PST January 16, 2008

It's no mystery that eating fruits and vegetables does a body good, but does eating certain foods burn more calories than they contain?

Dr. Timothy Harlan, also known as Dr. Gourmet, said the notion has long been a theory, but it has not been proven.
Fat-Burning Advice | Weight Loss Myths

"There is not substantive research to support the concept of a negative-calorie food," he said.

He said the basis for the concept comes from the thermal effect of feeding, which describes the calories used in digesting foods. Ten percent of calories consumed in a meal are used for digestion.

"For instance, in a 400-calorie meal, the body will use about 40 calories for digestion and absorption of the nutrients," he said.

Harlan said there is clear and well-established research that shows diets high in fruits in vegetables result in weight loss. But, he said, it is not because they burn more calories than other foods, but primarily because of calorie density.

"The best part of the foods that are on many 'negative calorie' lists is that they are -- for the most part -- fresh foods that are great tasting and great for you. It's easy to lose weight by simply substituting these for what most folks eat today in processed, pre-packaged foods," he said.

That means eating fruits such as grapefruit, apples, oranges and strawberries; and vegetables such as lettuces, tomatoes and cucumbers. These foods aren't packed with fat. Harlan offered a list of foods that he says fits the bill.

Add To Fruits, Veggies

"What I like to stress is there (are) definitely low-calorie foods," said Keri Gans, spokeswoman for the American Dietetic Association. "They can benefit your diet whether you lose weight or not."

She said the great thing about fruits and vegetables is peoples' ability to eat them in large amounts.

But eating these foods might leave people hungry unless they add protein and fat. Gans said all fruits and vegetables are carbohydrates, and therefore the body burns them quickly.

"If you want to incorporate negative calories into a healthy weight-loss program, they need to be incorporated into a well-balanced diet," she said.

Gans added that the balance helps people feel full. For example, eating berries with low-fat yogurt or a salad with chicken keeps people satiated longer so they won't feel the need to overeat at the next meal.

She also stressed picking the right choices of food: low-fat dairy, whole grains and healthy fats.

Eating these foods that may not be as tempting or glamorous as chocolate, cake or ice cream, but they can help get stave off temptation.

Deborah Enos, the One Minute Wellness Coach and author of Weight a Minute, said the good news is if people increase the amount of fruits and vegetables they consume, they are probably not going want as much junk food.

She recommended staying away from foods that have refined ingredients such as white flour or sugar listed in the first five ingredients of the product and processed foods.

"It's not about just adding good stuff, it's about deleting bad stuff," she said. Other Links:

  • Principles Of Healthy Living
  • High-Performance Nutrition
  • Metabolism Mistakes
  • Other Diet Features:

  • Brazilian Super-Berry Gains Health Status
  • Will Stunt Pizzas Crash Your Diet?
  • Which Fast-Food Breakfast Survives Drive?
  • Eating Too Much At Night? Try Breakfast
  • Which 'Big Burger' Worth Fat Bomb?

  • News Images & Video

    kirotv.com Video

    An employee of a Tracy, Calif., gym shares his experience after a nearly naked teenage boy shows at his work with a shackle padlocked around his ankle. More Details


    Police Release 'Toys R Us' Shooting 911 Call
    CNN Image
    Police in Palm Desert, Calif., release the 911 call from a double-shooting Friday in a local "Toys R' Us" store. More Details



    Shop At The Online Mall

    Sponsor Links

    Links We Like
    Sponsored Content
    Besieged by nagging aches and pains? You might have fibromyalgia. Read about the signs and symptoms. More Details

    So you want a cool job huh? Find out what you could be making to do something you love. More Details

    Paying down your debt is one of the most important things to do to get through a recession. Find out how you can lower your interest and escape your credit card debt. More Details

    Learn about 7 of the most common skin rashes and everything you need to know to avoid getting them and treating them if you already do. More Details

    Don’t be left out. Make the switch to Digital TV.

    Health Topics & Information

    An alarming number of people live with pain. Whether yours is chronic or acute, we can help you make it stop. Get pain management tips here! More Details

    Revolution Health

    Caregiving

    What If Chemotherapy Doesn't Work?
    Caring.com
    Get The Facts On Chemotherapy Treatment And Side Effects. More Details



    Caring.com

    Diet & Fitness Tools

    SparkPeople
    Get in the competitive spirit and lose weight! SparkPeople is challenging cities across America to get fit and we want Seattle to lead the charge! Go to SparkSeattle.com make it happen! Join Now.
    SparkPeople
    E-Mail News Alerts
    Get breaking news and daily headlines.
    Browse all e-mail newsletters
    Back To Top