Home Investigations 

Story

Downer Cows' Treatment May Be Illegal

The use of sick or crippled cows as a source for your food is the focus of a KIRO Team 7 Investigation this week.

Thursday, we first showed you how this high-risk meat enters a local slaughterhouse while federal inspectors stand by.

Now, we have disturbing new videotape.

VIDEO: Downer Cows Investigation, Part III

They're images that come with a warning: don't watch if you have a weak stomach.

KIRO Team 7 Investigative Reporter Chris Halsne witnessed what some experts are calling violations of the Humane Slaughter Act.

The use of what's called "downer meat" is allowed by law, but animal rights groups say food safety is just one concern.

Another is the treatment of the cows. Because downers can't walk into the plant, they are routinely shoved, dragged and hoisted while still alive.

Our video shows a typical downer. We took surveillance videotape of the Holstein at Midway Meats, a slaughterhouse near Olympia.

Unable to stand, the old dairy cow was dragged from its trailer into the parking lot. There it struggled in pain for about five minutes before being lifted off the ground by its neck.

Workers swung the wide-eyed, still kicking animal straight into the plant while a white-coated USDA meat inspector watched.

"See her. She's clearly still alive and suffering so much," says Bruce Friedrich.

Friedrich works for PETA, a national animal rights organization.

"This is clearly egregious animal cruelty. If somebody did something like this to a dog or cat, people would go to jail."

PETA says, given the secret nature of the slaughterhouse industry, KIRO-TV's tape is rare. However, the mistreatment of downer cattle is routine.

"If there were an F-minus, protecting consumer safety and ensuring animals were slaughtered humanely, the USDA would get an F-minus," Friedrich says.

The Owner of MidWay Meats says "there are a certain number of motions that are just reflex."

He says farmers bring him downers cows -- already injured, sick or suffering. He says he puts them out of their misery, then usually turns the cow into hamburger.

"The animal is anesthetized so it is not feeling any pain ... no senses. At that point the animal is hoisted out of the vehicle and goes into the plant," says Bill Sexsmith, the owner of Midway Meats.

That might be the plan, but our videotape, at times, tells another story.

KIRO Team 7 Investigators witnessed either ineffective "stunning" or no stunning at all. We also recorded animals being dragged around by the neck.

Dr Lester Friedlander, a former USDA vet trainer, is one of America's top experts in the handling of downer cows.

"It sure doesn't say much that that's going to end up on your plate. When it's dragged across the ground, you see what kind of environment it's in ... feces, urine and mud ... then all of a sudden it's going to be fed to your kids," Dr. Friedlander says.

So where does this downer meat get sold? To be honest, consumers have no way of finding out. You could buy some downer hamburger just about anywhere.

A number of fast food and grocery store chains have policies against buying downer meat.

However, our investigation discovered some of them are being misled by their meat suppliers. That will be the focus of an upcoming report.

If you want to comment on the use of downers to Congressional members on the Agriculture Committee, send them an email.

News Images And Video

Images

A man breaks into an excavator in the middle of the night and goes on a destructive rampage. View Images ››


Video

A Nebraska man says romance turned to revenge when he was victimized by his girlfriend and then exposed on Facebook. Watch Video ››

KIRO 7 reporter Richard Thompson said the South Sound was cleaning up Thursday after big trees fell down and hit power lines, causing outages.

Recent Reports

Anthony Gordon
KIRO Team 7 Investigators first uncovered that Western State Hospital handed a mentally ill man the means to kill himself, a conclusion that is now backed up in a federal report. Full Story ››
WATCH IT: Report Says Man's Death Could Have Been Prevented
Report From DRW On Gordon's Death

A famous Broadway producer and songwriter is accused of raping young Seattle actresses -- and a Federal Way woman is charged with helping him. Full Story ››
WATCH IT: The Role A Craigslist Ad Played

An exclusive KIRO Team 7 Investigation cracks open an international controversy -- uncovering how thousands of foreign drivers break our traffic laws with zero consequence. Full Story ››
VIDEO: No Reciprocity Means Tickets Go Unpaid



KIRO Team 7 Investigators had no trouble finding library books that contain hazardous levels of lead. Full Story ››
VIDEO: Children's Lead Book Test Causes Concern Nationwide

The state fines Seattle City Light after finding the utility mishandled a major liquid mercury spill that was first revealed by KIRO Team 7 Investigators. Full Story ››
INSIDE: Internal Documents About The Spill