Home Investigations 

Story

Downer Industry Thrives Despite Consumers' Concerns

A KIRO Team 7 Investigation exposed the business of buying and selling unhealthy cattle.

We've showed you how "downer cows" get past USDA meat inspectors and into a local slaughterhouse. Our hidden-camera videotape also revealed some questionable treatment of some animals.

Now, we follow the money trail.

When sick or injured dairy cows no longer produce milk, farmers either call up the rendering plant or take the cow to one of just a handful of meat packing plants, which will turn the downer cows into human food.

VIDEO: Downer Cows Investigation: Part II

Consumers have made it clear to us: They don't want to eat meat from these kinds of cows. But money talks, so the downers industry thrives.

Rich Van Dam is a respected dairy farmer, taking care of 400 head of Holstein. Occasionally, one of his "mothers," as he calls them, ends up a "downer," unable to stand any longer.

Instead of paying a rendering plant $100 to kill and haul away the cow, he profits by selling it to a USDA-inspected slaughterhouse.

"The downer meat, there's nothing wrong with it to me. I have a real hard time letting that meat go to waste," Van Dam said.

Midway Meats in Chehalis turns Van Dam's used-up milk cows into boneless beef. The process gets far more secret from there on. That's because it's not good for business to let consumers know they are buying downer hamburger.

"Why would you take the risk?" asks Dr. Lester Friedlander.

Friedlander is a former USDA meat inspector. He says after what he's seen inside plants like this, consumers need to demand downer meat warning labels on their ground beef.

"It's federal money, your tax money in this program, so I think the consumer should have some say in how they want their meat processed," Friedlander said.

Animal rights groups like PETA say food safety issues aren't the only problem with downer meat. They say our videotape of a crippled cow being hanged by the neck, still kicking, should make all consumers stop and think.

"Every time we sit down to eat, we make a decision. Do we support animal cruelty or don't we? If we're eating these products, we're supporting that cruelty," said Bruce Friedrich, with PETA.

Farmers like Rich Van Dam say that's unrealistic. People want beef, without knowing all the details about how it gets to the plate.

"There's no slaughterhouse that'd be a pleasant site to watch. It's the end process for a cow. It's sad to watch, but that's the way the industry works," Van Dam said.

Our investigation is far from over. We discovered some major food chains promising customers they won't buy downer beef due to quality concerns. Is it finding its way into their meat aisles anyway? That will be the focus of a future report.

News Images And Video

Images

A man breaks into an excavator in the middle of the night and goes on a destructive rampage. View Images ››


Video

A Nebraska man says romance turned to revenge when he was victimized by his girlfriend and then exposed on Facebook. Watch Video ››

KIRO 7 reporter Richard Thompson said the South Sound was cleaning up Thursday after big trees fell down and hit power lines, causing outages.

Recent Reports

Anthony Gordon
KIRO Team 7 Investigators first uncovered that Western State Hospital handed a mentally ill man the means to kill himself, a conclusion that is now backed up in a federal report. Full Story ››
WATCH IT: Report Says Man's Death Could Have Been Prevented
Report From DRW On Gordon's Death

A famous Broadway producer and songwriter is accused of raping young Seattle actresses -- and a Federal Way woman is charged with helping him. Full Story ››
WATCH IT: The Role A Craigslist Ad Played

An exclusive KIRO Team 7 Investigation cracks open an international controversy -- uncovering how thousands of foreign drivers break our traffic laws with zero consequence. Full Story ››
VIDEO: No Reciprocity Means Tickets Go Unpaid



KIRO Team 7 Investigators had no trouble finding library books that contain hazardous levels of lead. Full Story ››
VIDEO: Children's Lead Book Test Causes Concern Nationwide

The state fines Seattle City Light after finding the utility mishandled a major liquid mercury spill that was first revealed by KIRO Team 7 Investigators. Full Story ››
INSIDE: Internal Documents About The Spill